BankNotes ...

Small-dollar Loan -- Pilot Study Results Are In

Posted by Wendell Brock on Wed, Jul 07, 2010

Creation of Safe, Affordable and Feasible Template for Small-Dollar Loans

Small-dollar loan pilot

The Small-dollar Loan Pilot Project was a study to find if it is profitable for banks to offer small-dollar loans to their customers. Small-dollar loans were created as an option to expensive payday loans, or heavy fee-based overdraft programs.  This study opened up opportunities for small-dollar loans to be more affordable.    

Small-dollar loans have created a way to maintain associations with current costumers and opportunities to attract unbanked new customers.

Goals: The main goal the FDIC had in mind for small-dollar loans was for banks to create long-lasting relationships with their customers using the product of small-dollar loans. Many banks had another goal in mind in addition to the FDIC’s goal. Some banks wanted to become more profitable by producing the product while other banks produced the product to create more goodwill in their community. 

Where and how the study started: The FDIC found 28 volunteer banks with total assets from $28 million to nearly $10 billion to use the new product, offering of small-dollar loans. All were found in 450 offices in 27 states. Now, in the pilot study there have been over 34,400 small-dollar loans that represent a balance of $40.2 million. 

Template for small-dollar loans: Loans are given with an amount of $2,500 or less, with a term of 90 days or more. The Annual Percentage Rate is 36 percent or less depending on the circumstances of the borrower. There are little to no fees and, underwriting follows with proof of identity, address, income, and credit report to decide the loan amount and the ability to pay. The loan decision will usually take less than 24 hours. There are also additional optional features of mandatory savings and financial education.  

Long loan term success: Studies found that having a longer loan term increased the amount of success in small-dollar loans. This allowed the customer to recover from any financial emergency by going through a few pay check cycles before it was time to start paying the loan back.  Liberty Bank in New Orleans, Louisiana offered loan terms to 6 months in order to avoid continuously renewed “treadmill” loans.  The pilot decided that a minimum loan term of 90 days would prove to be feasible.

Often the bank will require the customer to place a minimum of ten percent of the loan in a savings account that becomes available when the loan is paid off.

Delinquencies: In 2009 the delinquency rates by quarter for small dollar loans were 6.2 in the fourth, 5.7 in the third, 5.2 in the second, and 4.3 in the first.

How to be most successful when producing small-dollar loans: The FDIC is reporting that the participating banks have found much success through small-dollar loans. But the most success came from long term support from the bank’s board, and the senior management. It is critically important to have strong support coming from senior management.

The small-dollar loan pilot has proven to be a great addition to bank’s loan portfolio, the FDIC hopes that it will spread to banks outside the pilot.

Profitability may depend on location: The FDIC has found the most successful programs are in banks located in communities with a high population of low- and moderate-income, military, or immigrant households. Banks in rural areas that did not have many other financial service providers also saw feasibility because of the low amount of competition.

Improving performance: Automatic repayments are a way to improve performance for all products not just the small-dollar loans.

 

 

Topics: Bank, FDIC, banks, Pay Day Loans, Banking, Bank Risks, Small Dollar Loans, Bank Executives, Loans, market opportunity, bank customers, Bank Asset

Bank Portfolio Management - Solve the Problems

Posted by Wendell Brock on Wed, Mar 10, 2010

It's a tangled mess in the financial jungle. In order to navigate the issues of portfolio management and compliance while still staying profitable and able to weather the market's unpredictable trends, financial institutions must arm themselves with the best information and resources. Yet many don't have either the knowledge or analytical resources to not only stay abreast of changing trends but also act on them in a timely and profitable manner. We have solutions.

New Rules, Economic Trends

A financial planner I know is now telling his older clients that the stock market is so volatile that it cannot be relied on as a stable platform for long term investing. Thus, the age-old saying that "assets are soft and debts are hard," has never been truer. In these difficult economic times, financial institutions need reliable information about their asset portfolio, including how the loans are matching up with the current value of the assets supporting the loans, along with the borrower's strength, all at a simple click of a mouse. 

By the time the CFO, CCO, CLO, CEO or any other member of the management team assembles enough information about the portfolio in a spreadsheet to make decisions, it seems the market may have changed enough to make the choice more difficult.  The analytics we can provide at a simple click of the mouse gives you 100 percent loan penetration and enough analytical information about your assets that your institution will have an objective defendable system to help manage the portfolio.  

Regulatory Requirements

The frequency and breadth of audits are increasing; requiring financial institutions to stay in a mode of continuous compliance, in one year's time they could be subject to internal and external loan review, IT audit, financial audit, CRA exam, and regulatory exams. Compliance is mandatory and with RiskKey, staying in continuous compliance is much easier.   

Industry Standards

There is a paradigm shift coming to financial institutions. Because lending is often formula driven, bankers need aggressively take on the roll of being asset managers. In addition to managing the loans in the portfolio, they need to manage the assets that support the loans. The tools and knowledge to help actively manage your portfolio are available with a simple, cost effective, mouse click!

Evaluate

With forward-thinking analytics, you can determine your portfolio's risk. These analytics provide a defensible probability of default within the portfolio, you can also stress test the portfolio along several different data inputs, including, percent of asset recovery, interest rate, fico score, and others. This basis can provide a direction as to the quality of the overall portfolio, all the while allowing the banker to zero in on the individual problem loans and assess their grade based on the institution's custom grading scale.

Act

Armed with a new, comprehensive understanding of your portfolio's risk, the analytics will subsequently locate the most pressing issues and provide options.

Assess

Finally, with your portfolio's risk evaluated and acted upon, you will have the tools and resources needed to clearly and concisely report your findings, to loan committees, the board of directors, and regulators.

Easy, Secure & Forthright

Working with us is simple. We take care of merging your data into a single platform. Your data will be protected and your analyses kept completely confidential. Our pricing is straightforward and simple.

People, Time & Action

Your employees should be generating revenue and managing accounts, not gathering statistics.  De Novo Strategy will allow your people to get back to profitable work. Our innovative practices are well beyond spreadsheets and simplistic reports. There's no laborious compiling of figures or making difficult assessments across a range of formats. Integrated reports and analyses mean less lag time between making a decision and executing it.

To learn more about Silverback Portfolio Analytics click and let us know. This will help you Build a Smarter Bank!

Topics: Bank, Bank Risks, regulators, Bank Regulators, Bank Asset, Regulations, Bank Policies, Compliance, Growth, real estate, Commercial Bank

Bank Asset Quality

Posted by Wendell Brock on Tue, Mar 02, 2010

The Risk Management Association (RMA) just released 2009 Q4 figures showing that the downward slide of bank asset quality is beginning to level off.

The RMA is a nonprofit with 3,000 institutional members whose goal is to implement sound risk principles in the financial sector. Their Risk Analysis Service data report was released in conjunction with Automated Financial Systems, Inc., and is the self-professed only gauge of comprehensive credit risk. The data utilize figures from 17 top-tier banks.

Showing Signs of Recovery

From the press release: "The leveling off of the deterioration of commercial asset quality from the third to fourth quarter is a positive indicator that the economy is showing signs of recovery," said William F. Githens, RMA president and CEO. "However, the business banking sector continues to be a concern and is substantially underperforming the middle market and large corporate lines of business."

But while the rate of decline in asset value for big banks is only beginning to level off, specialty lenders are enjoying quicker successes. AmeriCredit, CapitalSource, Allied Capital Source, and CIT Group all posted 52-week high stock prices (TheStreet).

CIT GROUP

CIT Group, a commercial lender to small and medium-sized businesses, took its first bond to market on February 26 after emerging from a brief, month-long Chapter 11 reorganization in December. The bond, offered at $667.2M, represents a portfolio transition from commercial-paper-backed to equipment leases. Hopefully, this shift will lead the way to longer-term solutions to loan portfolio instability and vulnerability.

CIT's bond is issued through the Federal Reserve's Term Asset-Backed Securities Loan Facility (TALF), also known as "Bailout #2." CIT got in on the Facility just before its rapidly approaching final monthly application deadline of March 4.

It's a start, but CIT needs to secure other, low-cost funding that doesn't come from the government. Their bankruptcy had followed on the heels of nine consecutive losing quarters that totaled over $5B.

Whether CIT Group-and other lenders-will be able to remain solvent after TALF's discontinuation remains to be seen. What we know, though, is that small businesses are counting on the success of CIT and similar lenders.

Word on the Street

A recent CIT report-auspiciously titled "Lessons Learned-A Case for Greater Optimism" -surveyed owners and executives of 220 American small businesses (as defined by annual revenues from $1M to $15M) about the close of 2009 and their views of 2010.

Key findings:

  • For 2009, 33% said their revenue "declined," and 26% said it "declined significantly"
  • 64% said it was harder today to manage their company's cash flow than it was 12 months ago
  • 90% agreed that current stimuli does not help them
  • For 2010, a whopping 53% expected their revenues to "grow," and 8% expected their revenues to "grow significantly"
  • 80% said they're now smarter about running their businesses
  • 70% said the recession made them better leaders

Bankers should look at a systems to stress test their loan portfolios in an effort to better manage the risk. There are systems in the market place that will stratify/custom grade loan portfolios, stress test the portfolio along various key data points (not just interest rate stress), provide the probability of loss a portfolio will incur. These systems offer many other items of information that are essential to managing the loan portfolio and its risk, to both the bankers and the regulators.

Topics: Bailout, Bank Risks, Bank Asset, stress tests, loan portfolio, Noncurrent loans, charge-offs

Subscribe by Email

Most Popular

Browse By tag

To Obtain a White Paper

BankNotes

BankNotes© is published by De Novo Strategy as a service to clients and other friends. The information contained in this publication should not be construed as legal, accounting, or investment advice. Should further analysis or explanation of the subject matter be required, please contact De Novo Strategy at subscribe@denovostrategy.com.